The outspoken culture minister, Kim Howells, last night found himself at the centre of a race row after claiming that the time had come to stand up to the “idiots” of rap culture.
Mr Howells, who previously attacked exhibits at the Turner Prize show as “cold, mechanical conceptual bullshit”, launched into an extraordinary attack on Rblack British music hours after the police had criticised the music industry for “glamorising guns”.
During a radio discussion on the killing of two black teenagers caught in the crossfire between rival gangs in Birmingham after a new year party, Mr Howells laid part of the blame at the door of British rappers.
“The events in Birmingham are symptomatic of something very, very serious,” he said. “For years I have been very worried about these hateful lyrics that these boasting macho idiot rappers come out with.
“It is a big cultural problem. Lyrics don’t kill people but they don’t half enhance the fare we get from videos and films. It has created a culture where killing is almost a fashion accessory.”
He reserved his greatest fury for the controversial south London garage outfit, So Solid Crew, three of whose 30 members have been convicted or are awaiting trial on gun offences.
“Idiots like the So Solid Crew are glorifying gun culture and violence,” the minister claimed. “It is something new. I heard very interesting comments about [violence] in Victorian times and thugs on the street. But they didn’t have these methods of popularising this stuff. It is very worrying and we ought to stand up and say it.”
Rappers who carry guns in their videos are “particularly sick”, he said.
Earlier, So Solid Crew were singled out for criticism by Metropolitan police assistant commissioner Tarique Ghaffur, who blamed a “backdrop of music” for alienating young men and encouraging them to use weapons as fashion statements.
But last night Conor McNicholas, editor of the music magazine NME, described the minister’s outburst as “deeply racist”.
“He doesn’t understand the culture. It is this idea again that we have to do something about these out-of-control black people in our streets and the nasty culture they are perpetuating,” he said.
“They are deeply racist sentiments. We have to be absolutely clear, the gun culture is a function of urban deprivation and not because of the music. The music reflects the experience of young people and doesn’t create it.
“There is more rap music listened to and bought by white kids in Swindon than there is by black kids in Hackney, and nobody is talking about the gun culture on the streets of white suburban Britain.”
Mr McNicholas said he was surprised that Mr Howells had chosen to roam so far from his brief, which mainly involves tourism. “He clearly doesn’t know what he is talking about. We have to recognise that these are young kids who are growing up in very difficult environments who happen to make music as a way of expressing themselves and their frustrations. Just because these guys are making music about the situation they are in does not mean they are perpetuating the culture. The music is not creating the problem.”
So Solid Crew, in common with many black musicians and promoters contacted by the Guardian yesterday, said they were sick of being tarred with the “drugs and violence” stereotype, and several refused to comment, claiming that debate only reinforced prejudice. Promoter Lance Lewis said it was nonsense to see rap as bloodthirsty and perverse. “No rapper condones killing, anyone who says that doesn’t know what they are talking about.”
A spokeswoman for So Solid Crew did say that the rise in gun violence had nothing to do with music. “It’s poverty and crime which are escalating. Cocaine addiction is escalating too. They are just reflecting what they see around them. Their music is reflecting society just as Robert de Niro reflected American gangster society in his film roles. They are out there trying to make a positive difference in British black culture.”
She pointed to the fact that Ms Dynamite, whom the police have praised for her stance against drug dealers and black- on-black violence, has defended the band, who played a key part in her own emergence.
Ms Dynamite has dismissed as “bullshit” the idea that the garage scene is inextricably linked with violence. “The media have blown it out of all proportion. Garage is a young London scene. That’s why people in power are afraid of us and try everything to shut us down,” she said. “There is violence wherever you go and the rave is a small part of it. It is a metaphor for life in general.”
She also refused to condemn So Solid’s Ashley Walters, aka Asher D, who was released from jail in October after an 18-month sentence for possessing a gun. Walters, a former child actor, had been the subject of several death threats before his arrest following an altercation with a traffic warden.
“I’m not one to judge, but he was naive,” Ms Dynamite said. “Anyone who thinks they can carry a gun in this country is in for a shock.”
Academic Ben Bowling, of King’s College, London, who is studying the effects of gun culture, claimed rap was hugely misunderstood.
“Not only Ms Dynamite but lots of other bands like De La Soul and Us Three sing out against violence and drug culture. Rap is a very wide church,” he said.
He believed it was unfortunate that Mr Howells’ comments had come at a time when “there is a movement on the street and in the music industry saying ‘no’ to violence”. The only way gun crime was going to stop, he said, was for communities themselves to reject it, as had happened in the United States.
RELATED ARTICLES
- EVs pollute 1850 times more than Fossil Fuel cars according to new study
- UK Warns that China is Preparing for Total Nuclear War with the West
- Jacob Rothschild Dies At Age 87
- UK Government-Funded Study Found Virtually No Dental Benefit From Fluoridation
- UK Elderly Couple Ordered in a Council Letter to Sell Their House as its Needed to House Migrants
Loading ...
As a parent, I have seen the influence these psuedo aggressive fantasy ganstas have on young people.
In a societal context of minimal opportunity for young people to advance along traditional routes to success and material wealth, these videos offer what appears to be another route to the same.
However, in order to achieve this females must be overtly sexual and be interested only in males who possess material.
Males by contrast must be strong, aggressive and have that material wealth that females are supposedly looking for.
Both must be combative and willing to take by force anything they desire.
The idea that children would naturally evolve into gun-toting ganstas, replete with a particular style of dress and attitude, without these videos to inform that social identity is absurd. The idea that these videos are merely the expression of a pre-existent subculture is equally absurd.
I have seen young people deface and destroy pleasant urban environments in the belief that only by living in squalor and deprivation can this received social identity be validated.
Television and media does not spontaneously occur. A handful of people decide what we will see, read, listen to; what we will know and what we will understand our world to be.
Music channels pumping out aggression to a predominantly young audience is the active and deliberate targeting of a particular section of the community. Our children! That what they are being targeted with is encouraging violence and socially destructive behaviours must be viewed as the deliberate sowing of social discord.
Divide and rule has long been a fundamental tenet of governmental and corporate practice. TV stations are owned by corporations. If younger generations, the most likely to populate a revolution, are occupied in aggression amongst themselves they are unlikely to stand together shoulder to shoulder and see the real causes of their difficulties.
The artificially created aggression and violence also creates fear and moral panics amongst the wider population and offers government the opportunities to introduce freedom-killing legislation to ‘protect’ us. That governments have deliberately allowed this social destruction to take hold is never mentioned or questioned.
To blindly and unquestioning accept whatever the media tells or shows us is to be a brain-dead sheep; destined only for more manipulation, hanging like puppets from the strings of those that exploit us for their own ends.
Those who would tell us that these rap music videos are harmless are either deluded, lying or are actively collaborating with those that are shaping the all-encompassing bubble of media illusion we are subjected to.
People make their own choices, Rappers don’t give them the guns and tell them to kill people. your just a racist prick Kim Howells. :)